The Bachelorette Gambled on Taylor Frankie Paul and Lost Spectacularly

In the long and occasionally dignified history of The Bachelorette, there have been questionable casting decisions. But selecting Taylor Frankie Paul as the lead for Season 22 was less of a gamble and more of a blindfolded sprint across a motorway. On 19 March 2026, just three days before the season was due to premiere, Disney and ABC pulled the plug entirely. The roses wilted before they ever left the vase.

A Franchise First Gone Wrong

Paul was a genuinely bold pick. The 31-year-old TikTok star, boasting 6.1 million followers on the platform and 2.3 million on Instagram, became the first Bachelorette lead never to have appeared in the Bachelor franchise. She was plucked instead from the world of MomTok, the online subculture she helped create, and from Hulu's The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, which became the most-watched unscripted season debut of 2024, surpassing even The Kardashians.

On paper, it looked like a savvy play for younger audiences. In practice, the producers appear not to have done their homework.

The Video That Ended It All

The unravelling came courtesy of TMZ, which published a 2023 video showing Paul physically attacking her then-partner Dakota Mortensen. The footage reportedly shows Paul hitting, grabbing, and throwing metal barstools at Mortensen, with a child audibly crying in the background. Police documents from the incident indicate accusations of violence towards both Mortensen and Paul's then-five-year-old daughter.

Paul was arrested in February 2023 on charges of assault, criminal mischief, and domestic violence in the presence of a child. She ultimately pleaded guilty to a third-degree felony of aggravated assault and received 36 months of probation, with four other charges dismissed.

None of this was exactly a state secret. Yet somehow, the franchise that prides itself on fairytale endings decided this was the woman to hand 25 roses to.

The Fallout Was Swift and Brutal

Disney's official statement was a masterclass in corporate understatement, saying they would "not move forward with the new season at this time" with a "focus on supporting the family." ABC slotted in an American Idol rerun for the Sunday timeslot. Romantic.

The dominoes kept falling. Cinnabon terminated their brand collaboration, citing that "recent allegations no longer align with brand values." The Tonight Show cancelled Paul's scheduled appearance. Even Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Season 5 hit pause, with Hulu mandating a one-week filming halt after cast members reportedly refused to continue unless action was taken.

The Bigger Picture

Paul's personal life had been tabloid fodder long before the Bachelorette casting. Her May 2022 livestream revealing a "soft swinging" scandal within the MomTok community led to her divorce from Tate Paul. She has three children: two with her ex-husband and a two-year-old son, Ever, with Mortensen, born in March 2024.

The season's winner, 28-year-old San Diego ocean lifeguard Doug Mason, got engaged to Paul during filming. They reportedly broke up in January 2026, with Mason flying out to see Paul only for her to end the relationship.

A separate domestic assault investigation involving Paul and Mortensen was opened in February 2026, with Mortensen subsequently granted temporary custody of their son. Paul's representative has stated she suffered "extensive mental and physical abuse" from Mortensen, allegations he denies as "baseless."

The Verdict

The Bachelorette's experiment with casting outside its own ecosystem was not inherently a bad idea. Bringing in fresh faces from the wider entertainment world could have injected new energy into a format that has been running on fumes for years. But vetting matters. Background checks matter. And when someone has a guilty plea for aggravated assault on their record, perhaps the red flags are not the romantic kind the show typically trades in.

Read the original article at source.